Privilege by design

Keep the privilege. Use the tools.

In early 2026 federal courts decided, for the first time, whether AI-assisted material is privileged. The answers turned on who directed the work, what the tool's terms allowed and whether confidentiality held. No design can make a communication privileged on its own; a court decides. These measures put a firm in the strongest position the law now recognizes.

DecisionWhat the court heldThe lesson
United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., written opinion February 17, 2026)Documents a criminal defendant generated on his own with a consumer AI platform, then sent to his lawyers, were protected by neither the attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine: the AI is not an attorney, the platform's terms defeated confidentiality, and sending the output to counsel afterwards did not cure it.Counsel directs the use, on a tool whose terms keep the material confidential. The court said attorney-directed use might arguably have been treated as a lawyer's agent.
Warner v. Gilbarco, Inc. (E.D. Mich., February 10, 2026; a magistrate judge's discovery order, with the plaintiff appearing without counsel)Work product prepared in anticipation of litigation with AI tools kept its protection. AI platforms are tools, not persons, and waiver of work product requires disclosure to an adversary, not to software.Work product can survive AI use when the material is prepared for the litigation.
Protective orders (D. Minn. and others, 2026)Courts have barred uploading confidential discovery to mainstream AI tools unless the provider is contractually prohibited from storing or using the inputs.Check the protective order before any discovery material touches a tool.
What the firm does
  • Counsel directs every use. The desk is open only to invited attorneys; clients do not use it on their own.
  • Enterprise terms, not consumer terms. Use only tools whose contract bars retention, training and disclosure of inputs, and document the choice.
  • Seek a non-waiver order. In federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 502(d) lets the court order that disclosure in the litigation does not waive privilege; ask for one in the ESI and protective order discussions.
  • Counsel the client. Tell clients in writing not to run matter facts through consumer AI on their own; that is the conduct Heppner punished.
  • Mark and keep work product. Record that the work was prepared at counsel's direction in anticipation of litigation, when it was.
How the desk is built for it
  • Attorney access only, by individual code, so every use is by counsel.
  • No text kept. The desk stores no question or answer, only a fingerprinted record of which agent did what.
  • Identity without content. Each agent's ERC-8004 identity is public; what it worked on is not.
  • Payments without client data. When the information buyer pays over x402, the payment carries no client facts.
  • A private desk for the firm. When a firm commits, the desk runs on the firm's own deployment and its own model-provider agreement, so the confidentiality terms are the firm's own contract.
State rules

One survey dated August 19, 2026 counts forty states with adopted guidance on AI, thirty-six of them addressed to lawyers and the rest to the courts, and reports that most of those state an explicit duty to verify AI output. State Bar of Georgia guidance says lawyers should obtain informed client consent before confidential information touches an AI tool, and the survey reports similar positions in New Hampshire and Missouri. These counts come from that survey and were not checked state by state. Read your own state's opinion before relying on any tool, this one included.

Trackers: Justia 50-state survey · NetForLawyers list of AI ethics opinions · State-by-state coding, August 2026.

Sources: Dentons on Heppner · Chapman and Cutler on Heppner · Bloomberg Law · Perkins Coie on Heppner and Gilbarco · Fredrikson on protective orders and Rule 502(d) · Fed. R. Evid. 502. Checked November 19, 2026. Nothing here is legal advice.

Compelled disclosure

When a subpoena arrives.

No system puts a record beyond a valid court order, and any vendor that says otherwise should not be trusted with a file. Protection comes from three things done before the dispute starts: a privilege that was never waived, an operator that holds nothing worth taking, and an order already on the docket. This page sets out each one.

What exists, and who can be made to produce it

RecordWho holds itWhat a subpoena to the operator yields
The question and the answerThe attorney, in the firm's own file. The desk does not keep either.Nothing. The operator cannot produce text it never stored.
The step recordThe desk operator.A chain of fingerprints: which agent acted, when, and on which published sources. It shows that a question was asked. It does not show what the question was, and a fingerprint cannot be reversed into text.
A rating or comment the attorney chose to sendThe desk operator.The rating, the comment as typed, and the fingerprint of the access code. Keep client names and facts out of comments.
The model provider's copyThe company whose model drafts the answer.Depends on the operator's contract with that provider. The pilot desk runs on commercial terms that bar training on inputs; a firm deployment should run under the firm's own agreement with retention switched off, and the firm should hold that agreement.
A payment over x402A public ledger.Amount, time and payee. No client fact travels with a payment.
An agent's ERC-8004 identityA public registry.The agent's name, job and limits. Nothing about any matter.

Six measures, strongest first

Before any dispute
  • Hold nothing. The surest answer to a demand for client content is that none exists outside the firm's file. That is a design choice, made here on purpose.
  • Make the tool counsel's agent. Under United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961), privilege can reach a non-lawyer whom counsel retains to help give legal advice. Engage the desk operator in writing, by the firm, for that purpose, under confidentiality terms and at counsel's direction. Courts apply Kovel narrowly, so the letter should say what the work is for.
  • Get the order first. A Rule 502(d) order provides that disclosure connected with the litigation is not a waiver in that case or any other federal or state proceeding. Ask for it at the Rule 26(f) conference, together with protective-order terms that name AI tools.
When process is served
  • Assert it. The privilege is the client's and the lawyer must raise it. Rule 45(d)(3)(A)(iii) requires a court to quash or modify a subpoena that calls for privileged or protected matter, and comment [15] to Model Rule 1.6 tells the lawyer to assert every nonfrivolous claim that the information is protected.
  • Stand on work product. Material prepared in anticipation of litigation is protected under Rule 26(b)(3) and Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495 (1947). Opinion work product, the lawyer's mental impressions, has the highest protection the rule gives.
  • Point at the statute. The Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2702, bars a covered provider from disclosing the contents of communications in response to a civil subpoena; see In re Subpoena Duces Tecum to AOL, LLC, 550 F. Supp. 2d 606 (E.D. Va. 2008). Whether a research desk is a covered provider has not been decided, so treat this as an argument and not a shield.
The desk's rule on legal process
  • Notice. When process seeks a firm's records, the operator tells the firm at once, unless a court order forbids it, so that the firm can move to quash before anything is produced.
  • The minimum. The operator produces only what the process requires and it holds, objects to a demand that reaches further, and volunteers nothing.
  • No back door. The operator has no access to a firm's file, wallet keys or client communications, and cannot be ordered to hand over what it cannot reach.
  • In the agreement. These three terms belong in the engagement between the firm and the operator, where they can be enforced.
Language to adapt

Engagement. “The Firm retains the Operator to assist the Firm's attorneys in rendering legal advice to the Firm's clients. The Operator acts only at the direction of those attorneys, treats all Firm information as confidential, keeps no copy of any question or answer, and will give the Firm prompt written notice of any subpoena, order or request for Firm information before responding, unless prohibited by law.”

Protective order. “No party may submit Protected Material to a generative AI tool unless the provider is contractually barred from retaining the material, from using it to train any model, and from disclosing it to any third party. Use of a tool that meets these terms, at the direction of counsel, is not a disclosure and does not waive any privilege or protection.”

Starting language for counsel's own review. Adapt it to the forum, the matter and your state's rules.

The limits

Privilege covers communications, not the underlying facts. It gives way to the crime-fraud exception. A search warrant in a criminal case is not a civil subpoena and is answered differently. State privilege law governs in state court and in diversity cases: in Florida, section 90.502; in Georgia, O.C.G.A. § 24-5-501(a)(2). The operator will obey a valid order. The design means that obeying it gives up no client content.

Sources: Fed. R. Evid. 502 · Fed. R. Civ. P. 45 · Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 · 18 U.S.C. § 2702 · Hickman v. Taylor. Case citations are given for counsel to check against the reporter. Checked November 19, 2026. Nothing here is legal advice.